Lesson Planning Framework
|
Post-Lesson Self-Reflections
Teacher Name Rachel Guilfoyle______________ Date of Lesson _2_/__18___/ 13 _
Focus of lesson _speech ostinato________ Date of Reflection _2___/_19____/_13_
Describe in detail reflections concerning the following topics. Cite specific examples from your observation as seen on the video recording and recalled moments experienced while teaching.
Assessment Considerations:
_X__ teaching pedagogy _X_ comprehensive lesson plan
_X_ proximity to students _X_ posture
_X_ communication through facial characteristics _X_ nonverbal interaction
_X_ effective interaction with students _X_ interactive class assessment
_X_ audible and articulate speech _X_ use and accuracy of modeling
_X_ eye contact to all students _X_ verbal/activity ratio
_X_ appropriateness of teaching strategies _X_ positive leadership
_X_ conducting gestures _X_ professional appearance
1. As I reflect on the lesson, to what extent were the students actively engaged? How do I know?
Most of the students were very engaged in the lesson. There were some parts of the lesson when some of the students looked a little tired but when I got them started in an activity they were very interactive and they participated.
2. Did the students learn what I had intended? Were my instructional goals and objectives met? What is my evidence? Yes, the students were able to perform a speech ostinato interdependently and they were able to switch parts. They also learned how to end the piece together. I need to be more consistent with how I cue the students to start. I also had the students do some warm ups. I need to be assessing the sounds the students are making to make sure that they are using their head voices when warming up. Some students sounded like they were yelling instead of singing and in the video I did not address it like I should have.
3. Did I alter my goals, strategies, activities, student grouping and/or assessment as I taught the lesson for individual needs? If so, what changes did I make and why did I make these changes? I did not change much of anything because they seemed to be able to handle most things. I had students who were near each other group up so they
4. Were my strategies and activities effective? What is my evidence?
My strategies were effective because I used a sequence where I had to model the poem and all of the ostinato parts and it was simple to layer in. The 2nd graders needed time to adjust and listen but they seemed to really like having different rhythmic parts. The students are showing growth and they were able to remember the poem. They wanted to get better at the speech ostinato piece as we went. When we played, “Charlie over the Ocean” the students really enjoyed it and they did not necessarily want to stop playing so we could learn another poem.
5. To what extent did the classroom environment (Respect and Rapport, Culture for Learning, Classroom Procedures, Appropriate Student Behavior, the Physical Environment) contribute to student learning? What is my evidence?
Students felt safe to make mistakes. I am a very friendly person so I had some students open up to me right away. I did have some issues with the classroom environment when it came to setting the students up in a circle because there was a drum circle for another class set up and we were too close to the drum circle to be able to safely walk around the circle to play our game. I think that for the most part the classroom environment was very conducive for learning; however, there were some student behaviors that I did not always see because I was very set on going through my lesson plan but I will improve that. The students did learn a lot of new songs while I was there.
6. Was my assessment effective and useful to my students and me? Describe an instance in which my feedback positively affected a student’s learning.
I think my assessment was effective when figuring out if the students could be secure on an ostinato without my help. I also was pushing for students to perform their ostinato with a steady pulse. I also think I could have added more feedback in some situations like during the warm up with the student who was using his chest voice when he needed to use his head voice.
7. If I had the opportunity to teach this lesson again, what might I do differently? Why?
I would have layered the entrances of the speech ostinato piece differently. I would have addressed the issue with warming up with the head voice and not getting too crazy when warming up. When setting up the circle for “Charlie Over The Ocean”, I should have had the students hold hands to form the circle and shifted it so it was not as close to the drum circle. I would have also modeled better intervals in “Charlie over the Ocean”.
8. Describe future teaching strategies, presentational changes, etc.
I plan on just automatically going into modeling the ostinato with less explanation so my lesson would have been a little smoother. I also think that I could have used proximity to my advantage during this lesson to make sure that students were fully participating.
Teacher-Assessment of Apprentice
Student name: Rachel Guilfoyle_________________ Date of lesson: 2/11/13-3/8/13________
Observations of Teaching for discussion:
Assessment Considerations:
- Aspects of instructional presentation (strategies, proximity, posture, pacing, etc)
- Interaction with students (speech, eye contact, communication, non-verbal)
- Reaction from students
Observation of Teaching for discussion:
Rachel was able to observe and teach two 2nd grade classes (one more often than the other due to scheduling). She was always well-prepared with well thought-out lesson plans, she always had more planned than she had time for.
Ms. Guilfoyle’s lessons were engaging to students, with appropriate scope for this age level.
Rachel was able to get the classes to a point where they were reading rhythm cards successfully. She also included warm-ups for classes.
What aspects of the lesson were successful? (include student achievement)
Rachel created charming posters as a visual for the students to look at when she was teaching the poems.
After students became familiar with the rhythms cards, Ms. Guilfoyle had them perform the rhythms with a ‘ClubCreate’ loop.
Students successfully recited 4-line poem, while adding in two ostinati.
Suggestions for instructional improvement? (describe teaching strategies, presentational changes, student/teaching interaction, etc)
I would suggest Rachel observe a little longer before teaching. I understand that she wanted to get as much experience as she could, however, more observation would have allowed her to see teacher-to- student interactions. This may have permitted her more options when managing student behaviors as well as rhythm instrument distribution.
Sequencing was off at times. I suggest exploring options when putting different parts together. Layering parts would allow for more student success rather than having all the parts begin at the same time as this tends to be difficult for this age level.
Rachel needs to be clear about how she begins the piece with students, then do it the same way every time.
Rachel usually started each class with a ‘name game.’ This tended to be a slower moving activity. Speeding up the process so it lasted 2-3 minutes rather than 8-9 minutes would allow the class to get started positively and move right along.
I suggest realigning the warm-ups to allow for appropriate behavior as it became more of a time for them to be crazy. Model the behavior and activity you expect so they won’t have any questions.

MUSIC 670- Lesson Plan #2
By Rachel Guilfoyle
Objectives:
· Students will warm up their voices.
· Students will sing a response to the teacher.
· Students will perform the “Charlie, Charlie” speech ostinato piece with accurate rhythms and steady tempo.
· Students will recite a poem rhythmically with actions to keep a steady beat.
· Students will sing a song that features do-re-mi, and do-sol intervals.
Sequence:
Anticipatory Set
Teacher will play “Charlie over the Ocean” on recorder and see if the students remember the melody.
Activity #1 –Warm Up (2 min)
1) Model acting like you are throwing a Frisbee!
a. The prep into throwing the Frisbee is when everyone breathes in for the warm up.
b. When the “Frisbee” is thrown that is when the warm up is sang out using the head voice.
2) Have the students imitate the way the teacher warmed up.
a. Have them throw it 5 feet
b. Have them throw it 50 feet
c. Have them throw it 100 feet!
d. Have them throw it accidentally into a tree!
e. Have them throw it as far as they can
Activity #2 – Name game! (3 minutes)
3) Using the Sol- Do melody say, “Hello *insert student name* how are you today?”
4) Have students respond with some form of greeting and an answer to your question.
5) Assess whether or not the students responded with singing , speaking or through non-verbal cues.
Activity #3 – “Charlie, Charlie” speech ostinato piece. (6 min)
6) Ask the students if they remember what the 3 parts of the “Charlie, Charlie” piece are?
7) Ask them to list the different parts.
8) Ask the students to think, pair, share “Which part is the melody part and why?”
a. Assess their knowledge of the musical element of melody.
9) Have the students recite the poem.
10) Instead of using words have the students use magic lips and pat the rhythm of the poem.
11) Stamp the rhythm for the “Down the hole” ostinato without words and assess if they know what words go with that rhythm. 
12) Have the students perform this ostinato while stamping.
13) Clap the “Bubble bath ostinato” without words and have the students explain which part has that rhythm.
a. 
14) Separate the class into three groups.
a. Poem group will pat their rhythm while saying the words.
b. Down the hole group will stamp their rhythm while saying the words
c. Bubble bath group will clap their rhythm while acting like they are ‘popping bubbles’ in the rests while they are also saying the words.
15) Have the students perform the speech ostinato piece with their actions.
16) Repeat #15 as much as necessary but each group needs to try to perform each part of the piece interdependently.
17) Assess if each group is performing the correct rhythms with expression.
Activity # 4 – Cobbler, Cobbler (6 minutes)
18) Teach the poem by rote with actions:
i. “mend my shoe” – tap hand with imaginary hammer
ii. “half past two” – tap on imaginary watch.
iii. “stitch it up and stitch it down” – Sewing motion up and down
iv. “crown” – outstretch hand as if offering or accepting money.
19) Recite one phrase at a time with actions until they can echo back securely.
a. Cobbler, Cobbler mend my shoe
b. Get it done by half past two
c. Stitch it up and stitch it down
d. Then I will give you half a crown
20) Recite two phrases at a time until they are secure with that then the students can move on.
a. Cobbler, Cobbler, mend my shoe. Get it done by half past two.
b. Stitch it up and stitch it down, then I will give you half a crown!
21) Then say the whole poem and have them repeat without assistance from the teacher!
22) When they are secure with the poem with actions by memory model for the students how the poem will work with percussion instruments.
a. “mend my shoe” with sticks.
b. “half past two” with triangles
c. “stitch it up” and “stitch it down” with rhythm sticks/woodblock.
d. “crown” drum performing one sound
23) Let students know that they will play instruments at the next class period.
Activity #5 – “Charlie over the ocean” – Rest of the class period.
24) Have the students form a circle by standing up and holding hands.
25) Have the students sit in the circle and walk around the circle singing “Charlie over the Ocean”
26) Pick a student to lead the group in playing the game.
27) Assess if the students are able to sing the song independently without the teachers help.
Lesson Planning Framework
|
Post-Lesson Self-Reflections
Teacher Name Rachel Guilfoyle______________ Date of Lesson 4/18/2013 _
Focus of lesson _Chromaticism________ Date of Reflection 4/20/2013 _
Describe in detail reflections concerning the following topics. Cite specific examples from your observation as seen on the video recording and recalled moments experienced while teaching.
Assessment Considerations:
__ teaching pedagogy __ comprehensive lesson plan
__ proximity to students __ posture
__ communication through facial characteristics __ nonverbal interaction
__ effective interaction with students __ interactive class assessment
__ audible and articulate speech __ use and accuracy of modeling
__ eye contact to all students __ verbal/activity ratio
__ appropriateness of teaching strategies __ positive leadership
__ conducting gestures __ professional appearance
9. As I reflect on the lesson, to what extent were the students actively engaged? How do I know?
The students were very engaged when I had them all close their eyes to do the proprioception because they were concentrating to match with the rest of the ensemble while playing instruments. I also had the students engaged when trying to figure out what fingerings would work best for their instruments but I think I lost the upper strings when I had to assist the cellos with shifting. I should have given the upper strings another task that involved the lesson such as, play through that pattern on the G chromatic scale too and see if the same fingerings work for that. Students were also very engaged when I had them listen to examples and then later apply that same knowledge. They also had to be engaged because they had to adjust to my conducting style and gestures.
10. Did the students learn what I had intended? Were my instructional goals and objectives met? What is my evidence?
The students learned how to play an octave of the D chromatic scale which is what I wanted them to learn. Some students struggled with the technique while others were very confident in how they were playing their scales. All of the students played their scale together. I was able to look around and visually see those that were not matching their peers as far as finger position. When some students were out of tune you could tell by the expressions on their faces at different times. I think I could have done a better job with assessing individuals instead of just the full group. I wish I would have had more time to assess individuals. In the video, I observed that the students were working through their parts diligently and they were at least trying to play it on their instruments before writing it down on the board.
11. Did I alter my goals, strategies, activities, student grouping and/or assessment as I taught the lesson for individual needs? If so, what changes did I make and why did I make these changes?
I did not alter anything; however, I should have had activities ready for those students who finished discussion earlier than others. I did have to move around the room and talk to individuals to make sure that they knew what they were doing.
12. Were my strategies and activities effective? What is my evidence?
I believe my strategies and activities were effective because at least 85% of the students were able to play through an octave of their D chromatic scale with the fingerings that they agreed on. I have my evidence on the video tape of the lesson. The students were playing the correct fingerings but usually the problem notes for intonation usually were because of transitions like a shift or low 2 to high 2.
13. To what extent did the classroom environment (Respect and Rapport, Culture for Learning, Classroom Procedures, Appropriate Student Behavior, the Physical Environment) contribute to student learning? What is my evidence?
Students were very reliable when it came to doing the correct thing. The students were appropriate when we were doing activities. When the upper strings were waiting on the cellos they were a little chatty but it was very controlled. With Mr. McClendon, they have a set routine that they must go through. The students were responsive when I asked them questions during this lesson but for some of my prior lessons with them they didn’t know how to open up to me. The physical environment is clean and organized but it would be nice if the room was bigger but they do well with what they have available.
14. Was my assessment effective and useful to my students and me? Describe an instance in which my feedback positively affected a student’s learning.
I think my assessment was effective because I was able to address that the cellos needed to shift instead of extending their 4th fingers in the chromatic scale. By doing this I was able to get them to apply this knowledge by playing their instruments as a group. I was looking for matching fingerings and for the cellos to shift at the same time across the section. I was able to give feedback in a way that made sense to the students.
15. If I had the opportunity to teach this lesson again, what might I do differently? Why?
I wish I would have asked more questions to get the students thinking for themselves. I shouldn’t have given away the answers the way I did. I think I could have been more effective if I asked the students “Why do you think that will work?” instead of just saying “oh that’s correct!” I wish I would have been more confident when presenting the whole lesson to students so I would stop to look at my lesson plan. I should have had better eye contact with the students. A habit that I have is that when I am thinking I look up and around the back wall instead of at the students like I should be. I think that it would have been cool to find a piece of music that involves the chromatic scale and gave it to the students to sight read through a piece of music that shows how important knowing the chromatic scale is.
16. Describe future teaching strategies, presentational changes, etc.
I like the current teaching strategies. For presentation, I could have had listening examples ready that involved chromatic music.

Lesson Plan # 6 Anthony Middle School
8th Grade Orchestra by Rachel Guilfoyle
Objectives:
1) Students will analyze how to play one octave of the D chromatic scale.
Materials Needed:
· 3 Pre-made poster boards showing the D chromatic scale pitches and leave space for students to fill in the fingerings.
· Handouts with the chromatic scales written out for cello, viola, and violin.
· Clarinet to model chromatic scale on.
Warm up:
1. Have students tune to the concert master.
2. Play through the major scale with two sharps (D major) in whole notes ascending and descending.
a. Assess intonation, attacks and releases.
3. Play through the major scale that has one sharp (G major) in whole notes ascending and descending.
a. Assess intonation, attacks and releases.
4. Play through the major scale that has one flat (F major) in whole notes.
a. Assess intonation, attacks, and releases.
5. Work on proprioception skills. Students will close eyes and play the following notes:
a. Open G
b. G #/ A flat
c. A
d. B flat/ A#
e. C natural
f. C #/ D flat
g. Open D
h. D #
i. E
j. F
k. F #
l. G
m. G#/A flat
n. Open A
o. B flat/ A#
p. B
q. C
r. C#
s. D
i. See if students noticed a pattern and have someone identify what they were doing and see if someone can label it as the chromatic scale.
ii. Model the chromatic scale on the clarinet to show some practical use of the chromatic scale in real music.
CHROMATIC SCALE
6. Have the students label out the whole step half step patterns of Major and minor scales as well as Chromatic.
a. Major – wwhwwwh
b. Minor – whwwhww
c. Chromatic – h(x’s 13)
7. Ask the students to listen to some examples that I will play on piano and label if they are major, minor, or chromatic.
a. C major
b. E chromatic
c. D minor
d. F major
e. A minor
f. C chromatic
8. Have students apply this knowledge by playing the D major scale.
a. Assess if students understood the pattern.
9. Have students play the D minor scale.
a. Assess if the students played the correct pattern of whole steps and half steps.
10. To each section (Cello, Viola, and Violin) give them pre-made posters to fill out.
i. They only have 4 minutes to fill out these posters and discuss their options for fingering.
1. VIOLIN
|
PITCH |
FINGERING |
|
Open D |
Open |
|
D# |
Low 1 |
|
E |
1 |
|
F |
Low 2 |
|
F# |
High 2 |
|
G |
3 |
|
G# |
High 3 or low 4 |
|
Open A |
Open |
|
B flat/A# |
Low 1 |
|
B |
1 |
|
C |
Low 2 |
|
C # |
High 2 |
|
D |
3 |
2. VIOLA
|
PITCH |
FINGERING |
|
Open D |
Open |
|
D# |
Low 1 |
|
E |
1 |
|
F |
Low 2 |
|
F# |
High 2 |
|
G |
3 |
|
G# |
High 3 or low 4 |
|
Open A |
Open |
|
B flat/A# |
Low 1 |
|
B |
1 |
|
C |
Low 2 |
|
C # |
High 2 |
|
D |
3 |
3. CELLO
|
PITCH |
FINGERING |
|
Open D |
Open |
|
D# |
Low 1 |
|
E |
2 |
|
F |
(shift)1 |
|
F# |
2 |
|
G |
3 |
|
G# |
4 |
|
Open A |
Open |
|
B flat/A# |
1 |
|
B |
2 |
|
C |
(Shift)1 |
|
C # |
2 |
|
D |
3 |
11. Using these fingerings, play through the (1 octave) D chromatic scale ascending and descending in whole notes.
a. Assess intonation.
If time allows have the students try to play an octave of the G chromatic scale.
